Grandma’s brown sugar fudge
- Preparation 35 min
- Refrigeration 2 h
- Cooking 10 min
- Servings 25
- Freezing Yes, it freezes well
Ads
🍬 The recipe card I lost
This one comes from my grandmother on my dad’s side. She passed away, and she left behind a whole stack of good recipes. This brown sugar fudge is the one I kept going back to. She had written it out for me by hand, I copied it down, and then I lost the paper. It is gone. The recipe itself I still have, start to finish, and it is exactly the one written below.
I make it every single year. I give some away as gifts too, in theory. In practice I have a hard time parting with it, because it is too good.
🥄 Old fashioned penuche, no candy thermometer
This is where my grandmother’s version splits from every other one. No candy thermometer. No soft ball stage to watch for in a glass of cold water. No forty minutes of beating, waiting for the mixture to lose its shine at the right second. You count three minutes of rolling boil, pour it into a big bowl, and whisk in the icing sugar. The icing sugar does the work that other recipes ask of your arm.
That method is hers, not something I came up with. In my kitchen it has never turned grainy.
🌰 Pecans, and the month of December
The pecans are hers too. Most Quebec brown sugar fudge skips the nuts, and I think that is a shame. The bit of crunch cuts the sweetness just enough that you reach for a second square without feeling sick of it. The semi-salted butter does the same job, right from the start, straight in the saucepan.
December is its month. A box of squares, some paper, a piece of string, and you have a gift sorted. If you want to fill out the plate, my chocolate bacon fudge and my truffles with Tia Maria and hazelnuts sit beautifully next to it.
Ads
Ads
⏱️ Three minutes, and nothing else
That is the only cooking measurement in the whole recipe. Bring it to a boil, drop the heat just enough to keep a proper rolling boil, and start a timer. Three minutes. You do not stir during that time. When the timer goes, it is done, and you pull it off the heat right away. The clock tells you it is ready, nothing else does.
🥄 The icing sugar does the work
Most fudge recipes have you cool the syrup without touching it, then beat it for ages until it loses its gloss. That is where people give up, and that is where it turns grainy. My grandmother solved it another way: two cups of icing sugar whisked straight into the hot mixture. Icing sugar is already milled fine, so it gives you the texture instead of making you build it by hand. Whisk until there is not a single lump left, then stop.
🌡️ No thermometer, anywhere
I have never used a candy thermometer for this one and I still do not. No 234°F to chase, no soft ball test in a glass of water. That is probably why this is the recipe I keep coming back to instead of any other. If fudge has always intimidated you, start here.
⚡ Get everything ready before you turn on the burner
Three minutes goes fast, and the next step follows immediately. Measure your icing sugar into a large bowl, chop the pecans, line the pan with parchment, have the whisk sitting right there. Once the saucepan is going, you do not have time to dig through a cupboard.
📅 It can be made completely ahead
This is one of the rare desserts you can make days in advance without losing a thing. Cut into squares, in an airtight container in the fridge, it holds for a few days without any trouble. Take it out about ten minutes before serving so it softens back up. That is also what makes it such an easy gift to prep early.
❄️ It freezes
I have frozen it, and it works. Cut it into squares first, slide a sheet of parchment between the layers so they do not weld together, and store it all in an airtight container. Thaw it in the fridge, slowly, not on the counter.
🍰 Soft brown sugar fudge for topping a cake
If you want it pourable instead of firm, to spoon over a cake or ice cream, the move is to cook it less. Cut the rolling boil to under three minutes. I will not give you an exact time because I always make mine as squares, but that is the dial to turn.
🌰 The pecans and the semi-salted butter
Two details that came from her and that I do not touch. Pecans chopped coarsely, big enough that you feel them. And semi-salted butter from the very start, in the saucepan, not a pinch of salt thrown in at the end. The salt cooks into the caramel. That is what keeps a square from tasting like nothing but sugar.
✅ What to serve with my brown sugar fudge?
It stands on its own with a coffee, and it vanishes. But if you are building a holiday plate, set it beside my chocolate bacon fudge and my truffles with Tia Maria and hazelnuts so you get three different textures in the same handful. My dark chocolate and fleur de sel cookies bring the bitter edge the plate needs, and if you are really entertaining, my honey and pecan pie picks up the same pecans as a sit-down dessert.
Ads
Brown sugar fudge
- ½ cup (125 ml) semi-salted butter, cut into small cubes
- 2 cups (500 ml) packed brown sugar
- ¾ cup (175 ml) 35% cream
- 2 cups (500 ml) icing sugar
- ½ cup (125 ml) pecans, coarsely chopped
Ads
Preparation
- In a saucepan over medium heat, melt the butter, then add the brown sugar and the 35% cream. Stir well, bring to a boil, then slightly reduce the heat. Let it simmer at a rolling boil for exactly 3 minutes without stirring.
- Pour the mixture into a large bowl and whisk in the icing sugar until smooth and lump-free. Gently fold in the pecans.
- Transfer to an 8 x 8 inch (20 x 20 cm) square pan lined with parchment paper, smoothing it evenly. Let it cool for 15 minutes at room temperature, then refrigerate for at least 2 hours until fully set. Cut into squares and serve! It keeps for a few days in the fridge. But if you love it as much as I do, it won’t last that long!
Three things, and they are all in the recipe. Simmer at a full rolling boil for exactly three minutes, timer running, without stirring once. Pull it off the heat the second the timer goes. Then whisk the icing sugar into the still-hot mixture until there is not a lump left.
The icing sugar is what builds the texture here, instead of the long beating after cooling that most old fashioned recipes call for. Made this way, mine has never turned grainy.
Yes. There is no condensed milk in this one at all. It is butter, brown sugar, 35% cream, icing sugar and pecans, and that is the entire list.
Condensed milk is the shortcut most modern fudge recipes lean on. My grandmother used cream and cooked it properly instead, which is what gives it that caramel flavour a can never quite delivers.
In Quebec this candy is called sucre à la crème, and in the rest of North America the closest name is penuche. Maple fudge is a different thing: it is made with maple syrup.
There is no maple syrup in this recipe. The caramel flavour comes entirely from brown sugar cooked with cream and semi-salted butter.
A few days in the fridge, in an airtight container, once it has been cut into squares. Take it out about ten minutes before serving so it softens back up.
It also freezes well. Cut it into squares, separate the layers with parchment paper, and thaw it in the fridge.
Cook it for less time. Dropping the rolling boil below three minutes keeps the mixture looser, so it pours over a cake instead of setting into squares.
Treat that as a starting point rather than a tested recipe, since I always make mine as squares. Pull a small amount out before it sets and check the texture you are getting.
Not for this one. There is no temperature to hit and no soft ball test to run. The timer is the whole method: three minutes of rolling boil, then off the heat.
That is the reason this old fashioned version is the one I keep making. A saucepan, a whisk and a clock is all it asks for.
Ads
Ads
Ads
Ads
Ads