Sandwich Loaf Recipe (Cream Cheese Frosted)
- Preparation 45 min
- Refrigeration 2 h
- Cooking 15 min
- Servings 8 to 12
- Freezing I do not suggest
Ads
🎄 The party centerpiece everyone stops talking about
Want to know which dish disappears first on a holiday table? This one. Not the turkey. The sandwich loaf! Four slices of white bread cut the long way, three different fillings between the layers, and the whole outside frosted with cheese like a cake. People see it land in the middle of the table and the room goes quiet, I promise you. Make it once and they will ask for it again next year. And the best part is there is NOTHING hard about it! Three fillings in the food processor, stack, frost, chill. Done.
🧀 The Boursin is mine and it changes everything
Everywhere else, the frosting is cream cheese loosened with cream or mayo. Some versions go straight to orange spreadable cheese. I put a full 250 g of garlic and herb Boursin in mine and I am never going back. Boursin is the greatest thing on this earth, and here it seasons the entire loaf at once: the garlic, the herbs, the fat that holds its shape cold. Try it once and you will understand why I refuse to even taste the plain version.
👵 My grandmother’s loaf, done a lot better
At my grandmother’s house, on my dad’s side, there was always a sandwich loaf on the table. Always the same one, with the orange cheese on top. I kept it in my head for years and finally rebuilt it my way: smoked paprika chicken, finely chopped Black Forest ham, and an egg filling loaded with bacon and aged cheddar. This is a Christmas dish one hundred percent, but if you are hosting a brunch or a New Year’s spread, bring it out anyway. People will be impressed, guaranteed.
Ads
Ads
🍞 Lengthwise-cut bread, and the backup plan if you can’t find it
This is the one thing that is not negotiable: you need bread sliced the long way, the tramezzini style loaf. From November on, every large grocery store carries it, it is the season for it. If you are really stuck, here is what I have done before: buy two large white sandwich loaves, cut off every crust, and build the loaf with those. Fair warning, slicing will be harder because each layer is not one single piece. But it works in a pinch, and nobody notices once the whole thing is frosted.
🧀 The frosting is Boursin or nothing
A brick and a half of cream cheese, so 375 g, with 250 g of garlic and herb Boursin. If you can’t find the large format, two 150 g packages give you 300 g and that works perfectly. Both cheeses have to be softened at room temperature before you whip them, otherwise you will fight the mixture and tear the bread spreading it. That tablespoon of hot water is not decorative: it is what makes the mixture loose enough to spread like frosting.
🥓 Bacon goes in after the blender, never before
The eggs get blended on their own, so you end up with a smooth filling instead of a chunky one. The bacon, though, you crumble by hand and fold in afterward with a spoon. Blend it with the eggs and it turns to powder, and you lose the bacon texture completely. That little bit of crunch is exactly why the egg layer is everyone’s favorite.
🧈 Butter between the slices, I skip it
Traditionally, you butter every slice of a sandwich loaf before filling it. The idea is to build a barrier so the bread doesn’t go soggy. I skip it entirely, because my fillings are built in the food processor and hold their shape, they don’t run. If you are nervous, or if you assemble several hours ahead, go ahead and butter the slices, it won’t hurt. But it isn’t required, and skipping it keeps things lighter.
🔪 Wipe the blade between every slice
Two full hours in the fridge, no less. The cheese has to set, because it is what holds the whole structure together when you cut. Then use a serrated bread knife and wipe the blade with a cloth between each slice. Skip that and the filling from the first cut smears down the face of the second, and you lose the clean layers. It is two extra seconds per slice and it changes the whole plate.
📅 Make-ahead prep
All three fillings can be made the day before, except the chicken. Leave the chicken for the day of: mayonnaise tends to stiffen with it and the filling dries out a bit. If you do make it ahead anyway, stir in a splash of mayonnaise and mix well before assembling, so it comes back moist. Everything else, yes: the ham and egg fillings keep beautifully in labeled containers, the cooked crumbled bacon in its own container, and the lemon zest grated ahead. On party day, all that’s left is the chicken, the assembly and two hours of chilling.
❄️ How long it keeps
Once assembled and frosted, count on 24 hours in the fridge, well covered. Up to 48 hours still works, but after that the bread starts pulling moisture from the fillings and goes soft. And no, I would not freeze a sandwich like this: cream cheese separates when it thaws and the bread turns spongy. This is a make-it-the-day-before dish, eaten within two days.
✅ What to serve with my frosted sandwich loaf
This is a buffet centerpiece, so it never travels alone. At our place it hits the table alongside the salad, the crudités and the turkey, the full traditional holiday spread. To round out the platter, add two cold bites that also get made ahead: my smoked cheese and bacon deviled eggs, which echo the egg layer exactly, and my Boursin stuffed mushrooms with pecans for the one hot item on the tray. If this is your kind of table, take a look at my beet and Boursin cheese tart, which cuts into wedges like a starter, and my chicken and grilled baloney club sandwich for the leftover chicken the next day.
Ads
Bread
- 4 large slices white bread, cut lengthwise, crusts removed (tramezzini style)
Chicken
- 2 cups (500 ml) cooked chicken, in pieces
- ¼ cup (60 ml) mayonnaise
- 3 tbsp (45 ml) plain Greek yogurt
- 2 tbsp (30 ml) pesto
- 1 tbsp (15 ml) Dijon mustard
- ½ tbsp (8 ml) honey
- ½ tsp (2 ml) smoked paprika
Ham
- 2 cups (500 ml) cooked Black Forest ham
- 3 tbsp (45 ml) plain Greek yogurt
- 2 tbsp (30 ml) pickles, chopped
- 1 tbsp (15 ml) mayonnaise
- 1 tbsp (15 ml) Dijon mustard
- ½ tbsp (8 ml) honey
Eggs and bacon
- 5 hard-boiled eggs
- 6 slices bacon, cooked and crumbled
- ½ cup (125 ml) aged cheddar, grated
- ¼ cup (60 ml) plain Greek yogurt
- 2 tbsp (30 ml) mayonnaise
- 2 tbsp (30 ml) green onion, chopped
- 1 tbsp (15 ml) Dijon mustard
- ½ tbsp (8 ml) honey
Frosting
- 375 g (1 ½ bricks) cream cheese, softened
- 250 g garlic and herb Boursin, softened
- Zest of 1 lemon
- 1 tbsp (15 ml) hot water
- ½ tbsp (8 ml) honey
Topping
- 1 cup (250 ml) sprouts and microgreens
- 4 radishes, thinly sliced
Ads
Preparation
- Hard-boil the eggs and cook the bacon. Let both cool completely. Crumble the bacon by hand and set it aside on its own.
- In a food processor, finely chop the cooked chicken. Add the mayonnaise, Greek yogurt, pesto, Dijon mustard, honey and smoked paprika. Season with salt and pepper, then pulse a few more seconds, until the filling holds together without turning into a purée. Transfer to a bowl.
- Rinse the processor bowl. Finely chop the Black Forest ham. Add the Greek yogurt, chopped pickles, mayonnaise, Dijon mustard and honey. Season with pepper and pulse a few seconds. Transfer to a bowl.
- Blend the hard-boiled eggs on their own until smooth. Pour into a bowl, then fold in the crumbled bacon, grated cheddar, Greek yogurt, mayonnaise, green onion, Dijon mustard and honey with a spoon. Season with pepper. Never blend the bacon with the eggs or it turns to powder.
- Whip the softened cream cheese and Boursin with the lemon zest, hot water and honey, until smooth and easy to spread.
- Place a first slice of bread on a serving platter. Spread all of the egg filling over it. Top with a second slice, spread the chicken filling, top with a third slice, then spread the ham filling. Finish with the fourth slice of bread, cut side down.
- With a spatula, spread the cream cheese and Boursin mixture over the top and all four sides, like frosting a cake. Smooth it out until no bread shows.
- Top with the sprouts, microgreens and thinly sliced radishes.
- Cover and refrigerate for 2 hours. The cheese needs to firm up, that is what lets you cut clean slices.
- Slice with a serrated bread knife, wiping the blade between every slice.
It is a savory party dish, not a bread. You take a loaf of white bread sliced the long way, stack savory fillings between the layers like cake tiers, then frost the whole outside with whipped cream cheese and decorate it. It became a staple of North American entertaining in the 1950s and it is served cold, sliced like a cake. The Swedish cousin of the same idea is called smörgåstårta.
White bread sliced lengthwise, sometimes sold as tramezzini bread. You need four large slices with the crusts removed. From November on, large grocery stores stock it for the holidays, and many bakeries will cut a loaf lengthwise if you call a day or two ahead. If you really can’t find it, two regular white sandwich loaves with every crust removed will do the job, though slicing will be trickier.
Three things. Fillings that hold together, so built in the food processor and not too loose. A solid two hours in the fridge, so the cream cheese sets and welds the layers to each other. And a serrated bread knife wiped clean between every slice. The chilling does most of the work: cut it at room temperature and the whole thing slides and smears.
I wouldn’t. Cream cheese separates when it thaws and the bread soaks up the water, so you end up with a spongy texture. Plan on 24 hours in the fridge, well covered, 48 hours at the absolute most. This is a day-before recipe, not a freezer project.
With the rest of the buffet: salad, crudités, turkey. To fill out the cold platter, my smoked cheese and bacon deviled eggs and my Boursin stuffed mushrooms with pecans are both made the day before, just like this one.
Ads
Ads
Ads
Ads
Ads