The best homemade creamy Italian dressing
- Preparation 10 min
- Servings 2 cups
- Freezing I do not suggest
Ads
🥗 I stopped buying creamy Italian dressing the day I read the label
Every bottled creamy Italian dressing I ever bought was some version of the same problem. Too oily, or too salty, or sweet in a way that tastes like candy instead of food. Read the back of a Kraft bottle sometime and count how many of those words you would actually put in a bowl yourself. I make almost everything at home anyway, so at some point I just built my own. Five minutes, a handful of things I already keep in the fridge, and it has been the house dressing ever since.
🍯 Honey and a block of real parmesan. That is the whole trick
Two ingredients do the heavy lifting. Parmesan grated fresh off a block, never the sandy stuff sold pre-grated in a shaker, gives the dressing a savoury depth that no factory can bottle. And honey instead of sugar takes the edge off the white wine vinegar and the lemon without tipping into dessert.
The rest is short: mayonnaise, good olive oil, garlic chopped by hand, Italian seasoning, dried oregano and parsley. That is it. No preservatives, no xanthan gum, no glucose-fructose syrup. If you are in Quebec I use MAG mayonnaise, which is our local brand; anywhere else a good full-fat mayonnaise does the same job.
🍝 Salad is the least interesting thing you can do with it
It dresses a salad, obviously. But it is a better marinade than it is a dressing. Pour it over chicken breasts or a pork tenderloin, give it two to four hours in the fridge, then take it to the grill. The acid tenderizes and the parmesan and garlic build a crust you cannot get from a dry rub.
It is also the dressing I reach for on a pasta salad, which is where most people are actually headed when they search for Italian dressing. It clings to cold pasta instead of sliding off the way an oil-and-vinegar version does. Try it on my Italian tortellini salad, or use it to marinate my Italian grilled chicken breasts. Cut vegetables and a bowl of it works too. Makes 2 cups, keeps a week.
Ads
Ads
🫙 Skip the whisk. Use a Mason jar
Everything goes straight into a 500 ml Mason jar, lid on tight, thirty seconds of hard shaking. It emulsifies better than a whisk does and there is no bowl to wash afterward. The jar it was made in is the jar it lives in.
🧀 Buy the block of parmesan. This is the whole recipe
Pre-grated parmesan in a shaker is coated in cellulose so the shreds do not clump together. That coating is exactly what ruins a dressing: it will not dissolve, it goes chalky, and the umami you paid for never shows up. Buy a wedge of Parmigiano Reggiano DOP or Grana Padano and take it down on a microplane or the fine side of a box grater. It melts into the mayonnaise instead of sitting in it.
This one thing is the difference between homemade and a bottle.
🍯 Two teaspoons of honey. Not three
No white sugar here. The honey rounds off the vinegar and the lemon and adds a bit of body. A local clover or wildflower honey is what I use. Buckwheat works if you want it darker. Two teaspoons is the line; past that you have rebuilt the bottled dressing you were trying to escape.
🧄 Chop the garlic with a knife, do not press it
Three cloves, chopped fine. Garlic powder is a different ingredient entirely, flat and dusty where fresh garlic is sharp and bright. A press bruises it and pulls out a bitter edge, so I use a knife. If raw garlic bites too hard for you, thirty seconds in the microwave takes it down a notch before it goes in.
🍋 Two acids, not one
White wine vinegar for depth, the juice of half a lemon for lift. Apple cider vinegar will do in a pinch but the whole thing turns fruity. Plain white vinegar is too harsh; it reads as chemical against the parmesan. No lemon in the house? An extra teaspoon of vinegar and a little more honey gets you close.
🥛 Too thick to coat a salad? Milk
Mine comes out deliberately thick, which is what you want for dipping and for a pasta salad. On delicate greens it can be too much. A tablespoon or two of milk whisked in at the end thins it without touching the flavour. Cold water works, buttermilk works and adds a tang, and pasta water works if you are dressing pasta.
🐔 The marinade window is two to four hours
Chicken breasts, thighs, pork tenderloin, chops. Into a resealable bag with enough dressing to coat, two to four hours in the fridge, no longer than six. Past that the vinegar and lemon start breaking down the surface of the meat and it turns mushy rather than tender. Grill over medium, roast at 400°F (205°C), or sear in cast iron. Keep a little dressing back, unused, to spoon over after cooking.
❄️ A week in the fridge, and better on day two
Sealed in its jar it holds a week. The garlic and the dried herbs keep opening up overnight, so the batch you make Sunday is better Monday. It will separate, oil floating over the mayonnaise and acid; that is normal, shake it back together. Do not freeze it. The mayonnaise breaks on thawing and comes back grainy, and remaking it takes five minutes anyway.
✅ What to serve with this creamy Italian dressing
On greens: romaine, arugula, baby leaves, anything sturdy enough to take a thick dressing. On my Italian tortellini salad, which is the pairing it was built for, and on a classic macaroni salad if you want something less sharp than the usual mayonnaise version.
As a marinade for my Italian grilled chicken breasts. As a dip with carrots, celery, cucumber and peppers. Spread on ciabatta with capicollo, tomato and arugula for an Italian sandwich that does not need anything else. And if you want the other house dressing in the fridge beside it, my homemade ranch dressing covers everything this one does not.
Ads
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup (125 ml) MAG mayonnaise (the best)
- 1/3 cup (80 ml) good quality olive oil
- 1/3 cup (80 ml) finely grated fresh Parmesan cheese
- 1/4 cup (60 ml) white wine vinegar
- Juice of 1/2 lemon
- 3 garlic cloves, finely chopped
- 2 teaspoons (10 ml) honey
- 1 teaspoon (5 ml) Italian spices
- 1/2 teaspoon (2,5 ml) dried parsley
- 1/2 teaspoon (2,5 ml) dried oregano
- Salt and pepper from the mill
Ads
Preparation
- In a large bowl, combine all the ingredients then season with salt and pepper. Whisk for 1 minute to mix well. We don’t want the dressing to be too creamy so dilute with a little milk if that’s the case. Place in the fridge and set aside for 1 hour for optimal taste.
Italian dressing is the clear one: olive oil, vinegar, garlic and dried herbs, shaken together with nothing to hold them. It separates in the bottle every single time, which is why you shake it before it goes on the salad. It is a vinaigrette in the strict sense.
Creamy Italian dressing takes that same flavour base and adds an emulsifier, mayonnaise in my version, Greek yogurt or cream in others. The emulsifier locks the oil and the acid together, so the texture turns thick and opaque and it stays that way. The practical difference is what it does on the plate: the clear version slides off, the creamy one coats. That is why it works on pasta salad and as a dip, and the clear one does not.
An emulsifier, and in this recipe that is mayonnaise. Mayo is already an emulsion of egg yolk and oil, so it holds the olive oil and the vinegar together instead of letting them separate. That is the whole mechanism.
The freshly grated parmesan does a second job most recipes skip. Grated fine off a block it dissolves into the mayonnaise and thickens the dressing while adding savoury depth. Pre-grated parmesan from a shaker will not do this, because the anti-caking coating keeps it from dissolving at all. Some versions use Greek yogurt, buttermilk or heavy cream instead of mayo. All of them work, all of them taste different.
Add fat that emulsifies. Start with 1/2 cup (125 ml) of Italian dressing and whisk in 1/4 cup (60 ml) of mayonnaise until it goes opaque. That is the fastest route and it works.
It will not taste like this recipe, though. A bottled Italian dressing is already carrying sugar and dried garlic, so you inherit both. If you are going to whisk anyway, you are two minutes from making the real thing: mayonnaise, olive oil, fresh parmesan, white wine vinegar, lemon, fresh garlic, honey and Italian seasoning, all shaken in a jar. Same effort, better result.
Yes, and it might be the best thing it does. The acid from the vinegar and lemon tenderizes, the oil carries the herbs into the meat, and the parmesan and garlic build a crust on the grill that a dry rub cannot match.
Two to four hours in the fridge, six at the absolute outside. Any longer and the acid stops tenderizing and starts breaking the surface down into something mealy. Works on chicken breasts, thighs, pork tenderloin and chops. Grill over medium heat, roast at 400°F (205°C), or sear in a cast iron pan. Always set aside a portion of dressing before the raw meat touches it, so you have clean dressing to finish with.
You can. Plain Greek yogurt swapped one for one is the closest substitute; it is tangier and lighter, and it thickens as it sits, so plan on loosening it with a splash of milk. Sour cream gives you something richer and closer to a dip. Buttermilk makes a thinner pourable dressing, more like a ranch.
What does not work is dropping the emulsifier and calling it done. Without mayo, yogurt or cream, you have a clear Italian dressing again and it separates. If dairy is off the table, a tablespoon of Dijon whisked in first will hold the emulsion together on its own, though the flavour leans mustardy.
Ads
Ads
Ads
Ads
Ads